Wholesale values are up. Prices are down. Days’ supply is climbing. While the market sorts itself out, the fastest win may be a car you already own. 

By Ashley Callahan, General Manager, PureInfluencer

Picture a gray 2019 Accord parked in the third row of a used lot. It has 61,000 miles, one owner, and a clean history. Recon wrapped weeks ago, and it’s priced within a few hundred dollars of every comparable car within fifty miles. On paper, it’s exactly what shoppers say they want.

It’s been sitting for 52 days.

Ask around the store, and you’ll hear it’s the market. Depending on which report hit your inbox that morning, wholesale is soft or wholesale is firming. Buyers are tapped out, or buyers are back. Last month you could make either case with a straight face.

The market debate matters. But I think it pulls attention away from the question dealers can actually do something about this week: what’s happening to the cars already on the lot?

The headline said values rose. Prices fell.

On October 19, Cox Automotive reported that the Manheim Used Vehicle Value Index rose 0.7% in the first half of October, to 207.4. In the same report, for the same period, non-adjusted wholesale prices fell 2%.

Both numbers are accurate. The index strips out seasonality, mix and mileage so you can see the underlying trend. The unadjusted number is what cars actually brought. Cox’s Jonathan Gregory called that 2% drop a normal pace for October, and he was direct about what’s behind the firmer index: leaner supply, not stronger buying.

Retail tells a similar story. Cox counted 2.21 million used vehicles on franchised and independent lots in September. Inventory grew 3.9% from August while the sales pace fell 6.3%, pushing days’ supply from 44 to 49. That sounds worse than it is. Most of it is the season, and days’ supply sits just one day above last September.

So nothing is falling apart. But 49 days averages across thousands of stores. It can’t explain why the Accord in row three is closing in on 60. Dealers don’t manage an index. They manage individual cars, each with its own carrying cost, price, and clock.

Buyers are still here. They’re doing harder math.

“Demand has not disappeared. It has shifted.” That’s how Cox Automotive chief economist Jeremy Robb summed it up this month. Since the pandemic, he notes, personal incomes are up about 48% while expenses are up 53%. Housing, food, insurance and energy all compete for the same paycheck, and what’s left decides what a shopper can take on.

So shoppers adjust. Some trade down a segment. Some keep their current car longer. Some buy older. Prices on eight- to 10-year-old vehicles were up just under 10% year over year. Robb is careful here: he treats price as a proxy for demand, not proof. Still, it points toward real appetite for affordable inventory.

Money isn’t cheap, either. Robb puts total interest over the life of a used-vehicle loan at almost $11,000 today, or 26% of every dollar a buyer pays for the car. In 2019, it was about $5,600, or 19%. That’s the backdrop every shopper on your site is buying in.

Now look at what dealers have to sell. Vehicles under $15,000 made up 15.7% of used inventory in September, down from 19.4% a year earlier, and they carried just 34 days’ supply against the 49-day market average. Meanwhile, the average used listing price hit $27,235, the highest since December 2022.

The cars many shoppers can afford are the hardest ones to restock. Everything else on the lot still has to move. You can’t swap every aging unit for something cheaper when acquisition and recon costs are working against you, and you can’t discount your way out of every aging problem without leaving gross behind.

That puts more weight on a part of inventory strategy that gets very little airtime.

Your website is already making merchandising decisions

Back to the Accord. It comes up in Monday’s aging review with a handful of other cars past the turn window. All clean, all retail-ready, all priced to market. The conversation goes where it always goes: drop the price, send it to auction or rethink the buy.

Fair questions. I’d ask one first: how likely is a shopper on our website to actually see that car?

Not whether it’s listed. Not whether the photos loaded or the feed is current. Whether a real person browsing the site has a real chance of running into it.

Every dealer site has a default sort: newest arrivals, lowest price, some relevance algorithm. Whatever the logic, it decides which cars shoppers see first, and by extension, which ones they never reach. Most of us don’t scroll to the bottom of the results or change the sort when we shop online. Car shoppers don’t either.

So a good car can sit at 45 or 60 days while yesterday’s trade-in keeps landing at the top of the results. The Accord is available to every visitor. Available isn’t the same as visible, and that gap is worth closing before you cut the price again.

Aged isn’t the same as unwanted

A car that crosses 45 days hasn’t proven anything except that it hasn’t sold yet.

Sometimes the price is wrong. Sometimes it’s the wrong car for the market, or there’s a condition issue nobody has dealt with. Those deserve an honest look. If a vehicle needs repricing, more recon or a trip to the lane, no amount of merchandising will save it.

But sometimes the car simply hasn’t been put in front of enough of the right shoppers. That’s a different problem with a different fix.

Our industry has gotten very good at diagnosis. We have tools that flag aging units, value them and time the price moves. But flagging a car doesn’t get it seen. The report tells you which units need attention. Your website should be doing something about them.

Using the traffic you already have

The fix doesn’t have to start with more traffic or a bigger ad budget. It starts with the attention the store has already earned. A shopper looking at a similar vehicle is the right moment to put an aged unit in front of them, without announcing how long it’s been on the lot. The traffic is already there. The question is whether the site is pointing any of it at the cars that need it most.

Technology doesn’t replace inventory discipline. Dealers still have to buy right, manage recon, price sharply and know when a car is done. Demand-driven merchandising should back up those decisions. When a used-car manager is fighting for a turn, and the website is quietly burying the cars that need help, the two are working against each other, and the store pays for it.

Before your next price cut

Pull your used days’ supply today. Compare it with August and with a year ago, then look at the specific units behind the number.

Next, open your website the way a shopper would. Don’t touch the filters or the sort. Just browse.

Where do your oldest retail-ready cars land? Do they show up next to comparable vehicles, or are they waiting for someone to stumble across them? Before you take more money out of them, have they had a fair shot?

Wholesale will keep moving. Shoppers will keep shifting. Affordability isn’t leaving the conversation. None of that is yours to control. How well you merchandise the inventory you’ve already paid for is.

There’s probably an Accord on your lot right now. Priced right, ready to go, and its buyer may be on your site this afternoon. Make sure they get to see it.

 

FAQs

Why did the Manheim index rise while wholesale prices fell? 

The index adjusts for seasonality, mix and mileage to show the underlying trend. It rose 0.7% in the first half of October, while non-adjusted prices fell 2%. Cox’s Jonathan Gregory attributes the firmer index to leaner supply rather than stronger buying.

What is used-vehicle days’ supply, and where does it stand? 

Days’ supply is how long it would take to sell every used vehicle on the lot at the current sales pace. Nationally, it rose from 44 days in August to 49 in September, largely due to seasonal factors and just one day above a year earlier.

Why are affordable used cars so hard to find? 

Vehicles under $15,000 made up 15.7% of used inventory in September, down from 19.4% a year earlier, and carried only 34 days’ supply. Prices on eight- to 10-year-old vehicles rose just under 10% year over year, a sign shoppers are competing for that end of the market.

When does a used car count as aged? 

Many stores flag units around 45 days, though the cutoff varies by store. Aged doesn’t mean unwanted. Check price, condition and market fit first, then check whether shoppers have had a real chance to see the car.

How can a dealer’s website help move aged inventory? 

The default sort decides which cars most shoppers ever see. Showing aged units alongside similar vehicles that shoppers are already browsing gives them exposure without new traffic or added ad spend.

Should dealers cut the price on aging cars? 

Sometimes, but not first. Every markdown takes gross out of the car. Before repricing a clean, retail-ready unit, make sure it has actually been visible to shoppers on your site.

Sources

Read Full Blog

Similar Articles

The Cars That Cost You the Most Are the Ones Nobody Sees
Demand Driven Merchandising, Digital Selling, Industry Trends, Inventory Management, Thought Leadership

The Cars That Cost You the Most Are the Ones Nobody Sees

Demand-Driven Merchandising Fuel prices are rewriting what used inventory is worth. The dealers who protect gross this quarter will be the ones who get their oldest cars seen, not just... Read More

Read Article
Before You Buy More Traffic, Get More From the Traffic You Have
Automotive Marketing, Demand Driven Merchandising, Digital Marketing, Inventory Management

Before You Buy More Traffic, Get More From the Traffic You Have

Demand-Driven Merchandising In a market with higher carrying costs and slower buyers, some of the fastest gains may already be sitting on your lot and your website. By Ashley Callahan,... Read More

Read Article
The 15-Day Lot and Demand-Driven Merchandising
Automotive Marketing, Demand Driven Merchandising, Digital Marketing, Inventory Management

The 15-Day Lot and Demand-Driven Merchandising

Demand-Driven Merchandising The 15-Day Lot We have never had better tools, better training, or better people. So why are we still setting the alarm for day 30? By Ron Morrison,... Read More

Read Article
The Half-Second That Never Cost You a Lead — the Nine Days That Did
Automotive Marketing, Industry Trends, Thought Leadership

The Half-Second That Never Cost You a Lead — the Nine Days That Did

Website Speed Fear-Mongering in the Blink of an Eye A website vendor told one of our dealers last month that our tag was slowing his website down, and that theirs... Read More

Read Article